settledsites (773) 771-7528

Law firm website examples: why most look the same (data from 5,101 Illinois sites)

Spot the difference. Your future clients can't either.

29% of Illinois law firm sites share a template with 10 or more other Illinois firms (SettledSites check of 5,101 homepages, September to November 2026), shown as a grid of 100 dots with 29 lit.
Every dot is 1 in 100 Illinois law firm sites. 29 of them share a template with 10 or more other Illinois firms. Source: SettledSites check of 5,101 Illinois law firm homepages, 2026.

Short answer: Most law firm websites look alike because they're built on the same few templates and say the same few things. In Illinois, 29% of firm sites share a template with 10 or more other Illinois firms, and 1 in 3 homepages use 5 or more of the same stock phrases. Some sameness is good: people expect certain things. But the firms that stand out are the specific ones.

If you've been searching for law firm website examples, you've probably noticed something: after a while they blur together. We counted why, across every Illinois law firm site we could find.

29%of Illinois firm sites share a template with 10 or more other Illinois firmsSettledSites, 2026

34%of Illinois firm homepages offer a "free consultation" or free case evaluation, so saying it won't set you apartSettledSites, 2026

13firms open with the exact same headline: "Legal Expertise You Can Rely On"SettledSites, 2026

Why do so many law firm websites look the same?

Let me start by saying that some sameness is good. You want the contact information, you want to say what you practice, and you want some kind of headline. And the state advertising rules, built on the ABA's model rules, are there to protect people and keep the playing field somewhat even.

But you're right. A lot of firms do look the same. Mostly because they're built from the same kits.

Of the 5,101 Illinois firm sites we checked, 1,484 (29%) run on a template or platform shared with at least 10 other Illinois law firms. Two WordPress themes alone cover about 1 in 7 sites. The big vendors build this way on purpose: FindLaw offers "a flexible layout that include pre-set palettes, image library," and says it's used by "over 17,000 law firms." Same palettes plus the same photo library equals the same-looking site.

The most shared templates among Illinois law firm sites:

  • Hello Elementor (WordPress): 314 sites
  • Divi (WordPress): 212
  • FindLaw: 171
  • WordPress default themes: 103
  • Astra (WordPress): 99
  • Beaver Builder (WordPress): 86
  • Avada (WordPress): 77
  • Justia: 67

SettledSites check of 5,101 Illinois law firm homepages (saved copies from September 24, 2026, plus 106 fetched live in November 2026). Wix, Squarespace and Duda templates aren't counted, since their code doesn't show which template was used, so the real number is higher.

People notice. One commenter on Reddit said a vendor's site was "pretty obviously a template because a few firms in our area have incredibly similar looking websites." A law office staffer put it more bluntly: "any other lawyer using the same service can immediately be identified by visiting their website."

What do they all say?

The words match too. 4,941 of the 5,101 homepages had enough text to read, so we counted phrases on those. A third of them use 5 or more of the same 26 stock phrases. 542 sites share an exact headline with another firm, and the most common headline of all is "Home."

The phrases everyone uses (share of Illinois firm homepages):

  • "Free consultation" or free case review: 34.2%
  • "Call today" or "contact us today": 32.6%
  • "Years of experience": 26.3%
  • "Trusted": 21.6%
  • "Compassionate": 20.5%
  • "Fight for": 17.3%
  • "Aggressive": 14.7%

4,941 Illinois law firm homepages with readable text, September to November 2026.

Can you call yourself an expert on your website?

It depends on your state. Here is what Illinois says. Rule 7.4(c): "Except when identifying certificates, awards or recognitions issued to him or her by an agency or organization, a lawyer may not use the terms 'certified,' 'specialist,' 'expert,' or any other, similar terms to describe his qualifications as a lawyer or his qualifications in any subspecialty of the law." When those terms identify a certificate or award, "the reference must state that the Supreme Court of Illinois does not recognize certifications of specialties in the practice of law and that the certificate, award or recognition is not a requirement to practice law in Illinois."

The word still shows up a lot. About 1 in 3 Illinois firm homepages use "expert," "experts" or "expertise" somewhere, and 160 call their own lawyers "experts" directly. Those are word counts, not findings that anyone broke a rule: "expertise" in a sentence, a quoted review or a real award can all be fine. But it's worth a second look. And Illinois isn't alone: 32 states are stricter than the ABA's model rules on "expert" and "specialist."

What does a law firm website that stands out look like?

Seth Godin tells a story in his book Purple Cow. Driving through France, he saw field after field of cows. Beautiful at first. Twenty minutes later, nobody was looking out the window anymore. But a purple cow? You'd remember that one.

To stand out, you don't have to wear a giant pink feather in your hat or dance on TikTok to hip-hop. (Although, I mean, at least you'll get likes.) You need to earn trust. You need to be human, approachable, and sometimes imperfect, and that's OK. You can be different, and a lot of the time it works in your favor.

Remember the long tail from our post on SEO? Same idea here. The more specific you are, the more you stand out. Compare these two:

Generic. "Experienced, aggressive representation you can trust." Said by hundreds of firms. Proves nothing.

Specific. "I've handled DUI cases in DuPage County courts since 2012." True, checkable and yours alone. Nobody else can say it.

Wondering how your homepage reads next to everyone else's? We'll check your wording against your state's rules, free.

Get a free website review

Questions lawyers ask about standing out

Can I call myself an expert or specialist on my website?

The ABA's model rules say a lawyer "is generally permitted to state that the lawyer 'concentrates in' or is a 'specialist,' practices a 'specialty,' or 'specializes in' particular fields," as long as it meets the "false and misleading" standard of Rule 7.1. Illinois is one of the 32 stricter states: see what Illinois says.

Can I post case results and client reviews?

It depends on your state. Many states add rules: Florida's Rule 4-7.13 requires a disclaimer on testimonials, and its comment calls for the client's informed consent to advertise a result, New Jersey wants "results may vary" language on testimonials about past results, and North Carolina's State Bar says testimonials can't include specific dollar amounts. More in our post on Google reviews.

Can a website builder template ever look unique?

Yes. A template is a starting point, not a sentence. What makes a site feel like yours is mostly the words, the photos and how the pages are organized, not the builder underneath. Real photos of you and your office, and copy that sounds like you talking, will do more than any new theme.

How do I check if my site looks like everyone else's?

Copy your homepage headline, put it in quotation marks, and search for it on Google. If other firms come up using the same words, you have your answer. Then look at the bottom of your site for a vendor credit, and ask your web company whether your design is a template other firms use.

Is "free consultation" a bad thing to say?

No. People look for it. Just say what actually happens: how long it lasts, who they'll talk to, and what they'll walk away knowing.

Sources

Written by Gaston Sitbon and Mark Jarvis, co-founders of SettledSites. Facts checked November 5, 2026.

Keep reading