Short answer: Claim your free profiles on Avvo, Martindale and FindLaw and keep them accurate. That part costs nothing and people do look. Paying for an upgrade is a different story: most lawyers we read who paid say it didn't earn its keep, though some, mostly in transactional work, say it did. If you pay, make it something you can measure and walk away from. And know that one company now owns all three.
Every solo gets the call sooner or later: a rep from Avvo, Martindale or FindLaw with a "premium" listing. Before you say yes, here's what we found in the public record, in the directories' own pages, and in what lawyers say after they've paid.
1 in 20Illinois law firm websites we checked (about 245 of 5,101) were built by FindLaw or Martindale-Nolo, now one companySettledSites, 2026
2.5%of the sources AI tools cite for lawyer searches are Avvo. Google is 42%.BrightLocal, 2026
Is Avvo worth it for lawyers?
The free profile, yes. Avvo already has a page about you whether you like it or not, so claim it, fix it, and add a photo. The paid side is where it gets murky.
Here's what some lawyers we read report paying: about $379 to $400 a month on one-year contracts, or around $75 a lead. One lemon law commenter warned of "8 crap leads for every viable claim." Another found out too late that they had agreed their claimed profile could never be deleted. To be fair, a couple of lawyers said Avvo works fine for transactional work, though not for criminal defense.
Avvo has also had its run-ins:
- In 2018, New York's Attorney General found that lawyers who shared their resumes with Avvo tended to get higher ratings. Avvo agreed to stop calling its ratings "unbiased," to drop ratings for lawyers who don't take part, and to pay the state $50,000.
- Between 2016 and 2018, bar regulators in 8 states told lawyers not to join Avvo Legal Services, where Avvo took a "marketing fee" per case. Avvo shut it down on July 31, 2018.
- Lawyers who sued Avvo over their profiles and ratings have mostly lost. Courts have treated the ratings as protected opinion since 2007.
Is FindLaw worth it?
FindLaw is a different animal. It's a directory, sure, but most lawyers deal with it as a website and marketing company. So "is FindLaw worth it" really means "is a FindLaw package worth it."
Some long-time clients say yes. One workers' comp solo pays about $4,000 a month and says he gets decent cases after sifting out the junk. But the complaints we read are about the same thing, over and over: the bill and the exit. One 17-year client agreed to $1,192 a month on renewal and says FindLaw charged $4,572.33 in 46 days. Another wrote in a public review, "They kept the web site, and we lost all the work we put into it." Several law firms have sued FindLaw over website work. Those are allegations, and none of them was decided that we could find.
If you're weighing FindLaw for your website rather than a listing, our SettledSites vs FindLaw comparison lays the two side by side.
Is Martindale-Hubbell worth it?
Martindale is the oldest name here, and its peer rating still means something to some clients and other lawyers. You just won't find a price. Martindale-Avvo's own pricing page says "Pricing available upon request" for every product it sells.
One lawyer's spouse described the offer he got: a 12-month contract at $400 a month, about $5,000 total, with no guarantee. On the other side, one lawyer wrote on Reddit that a Martindale listing brought in mid five figures over two years. So it can work. The question is whether it works for your practice, in your market, and whether you can prove it.
How Reddit commenters talk about lawyer directories:
69negative comments (62%)
9positive comments (8%)
17mixed comments (15%)
16neutral comments (14%)
111 Reddit comments that named a lawyer directory, January 2024 to November 2026, vendor promotions removed. 37 came from people who said they're lawyers; most didn't say. These are comments we read and sorted ourselves, not a survey, and people who are unhappy post more.
Who owns Avvo, Martindale and FindLaw?
Remember the Wizard of Oz? Different booths, one man behind the curtain. Avvo, Martindale-Hubbell, Nolo, Lawyers.com and, since December 2, 2024, FindLaw are all owned by the same company: Internet Brands, which is owned by the investment firms KKR and Warburg Pincus.
That isn't a scandal. It's just worth knowing that when you compare these three, you're mostly comparing products from one seller. In Illinois, about 1 in 20 law firm websites (about 245 of the 5,101 we checked) is built by FindLaw or Martindale-Nolo.
Do directories help you show up in AI answers?
A little. When BrightLocal, a local SEO software company, looked at 13,354 citations in Google's AI and ChatGPT answers for lawyer searches in 2026, Google itself made up 42%. Avvo was 2.5%. FindLaw was under 1%. If you're choosing where to spend an hour, spend it on your Google Business Profile and your reviews. We cover that in how to get your firm recommended by ChatGPT.
- Google: 42%
- Yelp: 7.9%
- Justia: 3.2%
- Avvo: 2.5%
- Lawyers.com: 1.8%
- FindLaw: 0.9%
Where AI answers for lawyer searches get their sources. Source: BrightLocal, AI directory sources study, August 2026. Share of 13,354 citations in Google AI Overviews, AI Mode and ChatGPT answers for lawyer searches.
What do Illinois lawyers have to do before paying a directory?
A few things, and they're new. In July 2025, Illinois changed its ethics rules for lawyers who get clients through, or pay, what the rule calls "intermediary connecting services," which is a mouthful. The rule's comment lists, among others, "A lawyer directory, referral service, matching service, bidding site, question-and-answer site, lead generator, or similar marketplace."
Three parts of the rule stand out:
Tell the client. Rule 7.2(c) says that "at the time of the connection or at the outset of the representation, the lawyer discloses to the client the relationship between the lawyer and the ICS and, if applicable, whether the lawyer pays to the ICS a connecting fee" (and whether it pays for advertising, ratings, reviews or rankings there).
Check the service out. The rule's comment says the lawyer "may accomplish his or her initial and annual due diligence via the sample ICS certification letter included in the Article VIII Forms Appendix or through other means."
Walk away if it won't fix a problem. Rule 7.2(e) says: "If the ICS fails to correct the noncompliance within a reasonable time thereafter, the lawyer must withdraw."
The rule covers a lawyer who "may accept a connection of a potential client through, and/or pay the usual charges of" one of these services. How that applies to a free profile you never paid for isn't spelled out, so if it matters to you, ask the ARDC's Ethics Inquiry Program. Other states have their own rules on this.
How do you decide if a paid listing is worth it?
Treat it like any other bet. Know what you're putting in and how you'll know if it paid off:
- Put your own tracking number on the listing, so the calls you count are calls you can hear.
- Count signed cases, not leads. A $75 lead that never signs is a $75 phone call.
- Ask for month to month, or the shortest term they'll give you, in writing.
- Read what happens to your profile if you cancel, and whether you can ever delete it.
- Give it a fixed trial, say six months, and decide on the numbers.
Not sure which of your listings actually send calls? We'll look at your site and profiles for free.
Questions lawyers ask about Avvo and other directories
Can I delete my Avvo profile?
Usually not the profile itself, because Avvo builds profiles from public licensing data. Check Avvo's current terms before you claim or cancel anything.
Does a paid directory listing help my Google ranking?
Mostly it buys you a better spot inside that directory, not a higher spot for your own website. A free, accurate profile with the right name, address and phone number helps Google trust your details. Paying for placement doesn't change that much.
What happens to my listing if I cancel?
Your free profile usually stays and the paid extras go away: the badge, the top placement, the ads on competitors' pages. One lawyer said his rating dropped after he stopped paying, though that was one person, years ago.
Are FindLaw's call reports accurate?
Check them yourself. Test-call your tracking number from a cell phone, and compare what you count with what the report says before you renew.
Which directories are worth a free profile?
Start with your Google Business Profile, by far the biggest source in the AI answers study above, then Yelp, Justia, Avvo and your state bar's directory. Keep your name, address and phone number exactly the same everywhere. Free, accurate and consistent beats paid and scattered.
Sources
- New York Attorney General, agreement with Avvo, September 2018
- Hinshaw and Culbertson on the state ethics opinions and Avvo Legal Services
- Thomson Reuters, sale of FindLaw to Internet Brands, December 2024
- Martindale-Avvo pricing page
- BrightLocal (a local SEO software company), AI directory sources study, August 2026
- Illinois Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 7.2 and Comments, amended April 1, 2025, effective July 1, 2025
- Sample Rule 7.2(c) certification letter
- Law.com on Internet Brands combining Martindale and Avvo, October 2018
- LawNext on lawyer suits against Avvo: 2007 and 2016
- Law firm suits over FindLaw website work (allegations): The Legal Intelligencer, 2018; Connecticut Law Tribune, 2024
- SettledSites crawl of 5,101 Illinois law firm homepages (saved copies from September 24, 2026, plus 106 fetched November 4, 2026)
- Reddit comments, January 2024 to November 2026, including those quoted or described: $379 a month, 8 crap leads, profile never deleted, transactional work, criminal defense, workers' comp solo, 12-month offer, Martindale listing, rating drop
- Public reviews quoted: FindLaw renewal, "They kept the web site"
Written by Gaston Sitbon and Mark Jarvis, co-founders of SettledSites. Facts checked November 5, 2026.
Keep reading
See your own firm's new homepage before you pay anything.


