Do you own your law firm website? What you keep (and lose) when you leave
Some of it goes in the box. Some of it stays behind.
Short answer: Maybe. "Your website" is really several things: the domain, the site itself, the words and photos, and the Google accounts around it. You can own some and lose others. The only way to know is to do what lawyers do every day: read the terms. Most big legal vendors don't publish theirs.
"When you stop paying, the website goes away." That's a comment on Reddit, and you hear it all the time, and sometimes it's true. Here's what you actually own, what each big vendor says about it, and how to leave without losing the parts that matter.
Before you cancel anything, read this. As long as your current site is still live, SettledSites can pull all of your content off it: every page, every photo, every bio. Then we rebuild it on a site you own, and make it better. Once the contract ends and the site goes dark, that content can be gone for good. So talk to us first, and cancel second. Get a free review of what we can save.
2 of 8website vendors we checked publish clear ownership and exit termsSettledSites, November 2026
659Illinois law firm sites are on Wix or Squarespace. Leave either one and you'll be rebuilding your site.SettledSites check of 5,101 sites
Who owns your law firm website?
You have to break it down into smaller pieces, because each one can belong to someone different.
The domain. Your web address, like yourfirm.com. This is the easiest piece to keep, as long as it's registered in your name. If the vendor registered it in theirs, you're asking permission to take your own address. Check who's listed as the registrant today, not when you leave.
The website itself. The design, the code and the system it runs on. This is the piece that usually stays with the vendor. Even LawLytics, which publishes its terms, keeps "all software, technology, trademarks, branding, documentation, designs." On builders like Wix, the site can't run anywhere else.
Your words and photos. The content. Often yours on paper, but hard to get out of a closed system. One commenter put it well: "you own the content but the CMS is theirs."
Ever see content pulled out of a website? In a WordPress export file, your words are in there, but wrapped in code and settings that only make sense inside the old system. No design, no layout, no images, just text and tags.
Your Google Business Profile. Your reviews live here, so this one hurts most to lose. Only the profile's primary owner can hand ownership to someone else. If an agency set it up under their account, they hold the keys.
Analytics, Search Console, ad accounts and email. Your traffic history, your search data, your ad history, and the settings that make your email work. Many complaints we read weren't about the website at all. They were about these accounts staying in the vendor's hands. One firm's complaint says its old vendor's account kept primary owner control after three written transfer requests. The vendor's public reply says ownership was transferred on June 29, 2026, the day the complaint was filed.
What happens when you leave FindLaw, Scorpion or other vendors?
It all depends on where you are, and on what you signed. Here's what each vendor publishes, and what lawyers, marketers and reviewers report.
- LawLytics. Public terms: yes. What you keep: your content, with 30 days to export it. Design and platform stay. What people report: mixed. Some say moving off is hard.
- Squarespace. Public terms: yes. What you keep: "Your User Content stays yours." Export is partial: some pages, one blog, no design. What people report: easy to cancel, hard to move.
- Wix. Public terms: yes. What you keep: the domain. The site "needs to be hosted and operated on Wix's servers." Blog posts can't be exported. What people report: leaving means rebuilding.
- FindLaw. Public terms: no. What you keep: depends on your agreement. What people report: one reviewer says FindLaw kept the site and the firm lost its work. A marketing advisor says FindLaw lets you keep site, content and domain if you finish the contract term.
- Scorpion. Public terms: not reachable. What you keep: depends on your agreement. What people report: 6 of the 8 reviews we read about not owning the site.
- Martindale-Nolo. Public terms: no. What you keep: depends on your agreement. What people report: a marketer says leaving usually means starting from scratch.
- Justia, Legalfit. Public terms: no. What you keep: depends on your agreement. What people report: Legalfit, you own the content, not the platform it runs on.
Published terms read November 5, 2026, plus what lawyers, marketers and reviewers report.
The pattern is simple. The companies that publish clear exit terms are the ones you can leave. For everyone else, the terms only exist in what you sign, so ask for the full agreement before you sign it, not after.
How do you take your website with you?
Before you leave, take stock of what you have. There's almost always something worth saving: pages that rank, reviews, a domain with years of history. Salvage the good parts, then improve on the rest.
That's the part SettledSites does for you. While your old site is still up, we copy every page and image, then rebuild it on a site in your name. You don't have to save anything by hand.
If you'd rather do it yourself, here's the order we'd do it in, and every step comes from the official help pages:
- Find the signed agreement. Read the parts on ownership, term, renewal and notice before you say anything.
- Secure the domain. Make sure the registrant is you. Ask for the transfer code; the registrar has to give it to you within 5 days. Under current ICANN rules, changing the owner's name or email can lock transfers for up to 60 days, so don't change them right before you move.
- Write down every DNS record before anything moves, especially the email (MX) records. New email settings can take up to 72 hours to work.
- Export your content. Take whatever the platform allows. On closed systems, save every page's text and images by hand, and list every page address.
- Take back your Google Business Profile. Make sure an account you control is the primary owner.
- Google Analytics: your own account gets Administrator.
- Search Console: you become a verified owner, and you remove the vendor.
- Ad accounts: make sure Google Ads and Local Services Ads are in your name.
- Redirect old pages. On the new site, point every old page address to its new one with a permanent redirect. Google says keep them at least a year.
Thinking of leaving? Before you do, let us look at what you have, and what's worth saving. Free.
How many Illinois firms does this affect?
About 1 in 5. Of the 5,101 Illinois law firm websites we checked, roughly 1,000 run on a legal vendor's platform or a website builder that limits how you can move the site. 659 are on Wix or Squarespace alone, where the whole site can't be moved to another host. But we can do it for you.
- Wix: 350
- Squarespace: 309
- FindLaw: 180
- Martindale-Nolo: 67
- Justia: 67
- LawLytics: 51
Illinois firm sites on platforms you can't easily take with you. SettledSites check of 5,101 Illinois law firm homepages, November 2026.
What are SettledSites' terms?
Here are ours, in plain words. No fine print, no hostage situation.
What's yours stays yours.
- Your domain is registered in your name.
- Your Google Business Profile, Analytics and Search Console are in your name, with your own owner access.
- If you leave, you take your whole site with you, with all the design work attached. No bare-bones pages of code.
Our prices and plans are on the pricing page, in full.
Questions lawyers ask about owning their website
What happens to my website if I cancel with my current website company?
It depends on your agreement, and the site may go dark the day the contract ends. Do the steps in how to take your website with you before you give notice.
Will my email go down when I switch website companies?
Only if the MX records, the domain settings your email runs on, get lost in the move. Switch on a quiet day. Steps are in how to take your website with you.
Do I own my domain if the vendor registered it?
Check who's listed as the registrant at the registrar. If it's the vendor, ask them in writing to move it into your name now, while things are friendly.
Can I move my Wix site to another host?
The domain, yes. The site, no: it has to be rebuilt. More in Wix, Squarespace or WordPress for lawyers.
How do I get my Google Business Profile back from an agency?
Ask the agency to make you primary owner, since only the primary owner can transfer it. If they won't, go to business.google.com/add, find your business and click Request Access. The current owner has 3 days to respond, and Google walks you through the next steps from there.
Sources
- LawLytics Terms of Service
- Squarespace Terms of Service and export help page
- Wix help: exporting your site
- Wix help: exporting blog posts
- ICANN, domain name holder FAQs
- Google Business Profile ownership help
- Google Business Profile, request access to a profile
- Google Workspace, set up MX records
- Google Analytics, add and manage users
- Google Search Console, owners and users
- Google Search Central, site moves
- SettledSites check of 5,101 Illinois law firm homepages, November 2026
- Lawyer comments on Reddit and public vendor reviews, 2023 to 2026
Written by Gaston Sitbon and Mark Jarvis, co-founders of SettledSites. Facts checked November 5, 2026.
Keep reading
See your own firm's new homepage before you pay anything.


