settledsites (773) 771-7528

5,241 Illinois law firm websites. 830 of them are turning clients away.

Do you run a law firm in Illinois? Is your site one of the 830? Here's what I found, and a two-minute test to find out.

Dot grid of 5,241 Illinois law firm websites checked in October 2026, with 830 highlighted in red. Headline: 830 Illinois law firms are losing clients before the phone rings. Below: 337 don't load at all, 341 show "Not secure," 269 break on a phone.
Every dot is an Illinois law firm website. The red ones turn clients away.

Short answer: In October 2026 I checked the website of every Illinois law firm I could find. 830 of 5,241 sites (16%) had at least one problem a potential client would hit in the first ten seconds: the site didn't load, the browser called it "Not secure," or it broke on a phone. And 5,078 firms didn't say what anything costs.

How I ended up looking

I'm building LawyerPricing, a directory where people can compare Illinois lawyers by what they charge. To list a firm, the crawler has to visit its website. I expected the hard part to be finding prices.

The hard part turned out to be finding websites that worked. Firm after firm, I'd click through from Google and land on a security warning, a blank page or a "this domain is for sale" ad. These weren't abandoned practices. They were firms still answering the phone, still listed on Google, still sending people to a dead end.

So I stopped and counted.

What I found

337 firms have a website that doesn't load at all. That's 6% of every firm site I checked. Some domains no longer pointed anywhere. Some threw a security error instead of a homepage. 37 had become "this domain is for sale" pages, and 56 returned "page not found" on the homepage itself. Every one of those firms is still on Google Maps, bar directories and old business cards.

341 firms still show "Not secure." That's 7% of the 4,799 sites that loaded, still served over plain http://. Chrome and Safari print "Not secure" right next to the firm's name, on the page where someone is deciding whether to trust you with a divorce, a DUI or a parent's estate.

269 firms have a site that breaks on a phone. Their homepages were missing the one line of code that tells a phone how to display a page. The result: tiny text, sideways scrolling and pinch-to-zoom, on the device most people use to look up a lawyer.

611 firms have a site that's one page or close to it. That's 12% of all firm sites, with two pages or fewer. No page per practice area, no attorney bio, nothing that answers the question the client actually typed into Google.

5,078 firms don't say what anything costs. Only 104 of 5,182 firm websites (2%) published a clearly labeled fee anywhere. In employment law it was zero out of 1,157. Not every matter can be priced up front. But "what will this cost me?" is the first question almost everyone has, and almost no firm site even starts to answer it.

And those are the firms with a website. Of 9,861 Illinois firms I found on Google, about 2,400 (24%) didn't list one at all.

What one bad first click costs

A potential client rarely calls five firms and compares. In Clio's survey of 2,000 legal consumers, 42% stopped looking once the first firm made a good impression.

Now flip it. If your site is the one throwing a security warning, nobody tries harder to reach you. They tap back and call the next name on Google, and that firm gets the 42%.

It isn't a small sale either. Illinois lawyers bill an average of $349 an hour (Clio, 2025). A matter that takes ten hours is $3,490 in fees, and plenty of matters run well past ten hours.

The worst part is that you never see it. There's no missed call in your log and no bounced email. The client who left simply never shows up.

If each of the 830 firms lost just one ten-hour client this year, that's about $2.9 million in fees walking to another firm.

This isn't about lawyers not caring

Nobody decides to let their website die. It happens because a website is a buy-once purchase for most small firms. Someone builds it, the firm pays, and then nobody owns it.

The pattern is usually the same. The domain renewal notice goes to an old email address. The security certificate expires quietly. The developer moves on. An associate who left years ago is still on the team page. A fee changes, and updating the site means finding a login nobody remembers.

The site drifts, and nobody at the firm ever looks at it the way a stranger does.

Take the two-minute test

Pick up your phone, not your office computer, open your firm's website and answer five questions.

The two-minute test

Is your site one of the 830?

Open your firm's website on your phone, then answer 5 questions. Nothing is sent anywhere until you ask for a review.

  1. Question 1 of 5

    Does it load in a few seconds, with no security warning?

  2. Question 2 of 5

    Does the address bar show a padlock, not "Not secure"?

  3. Question 3 of 5

    Can you read it without zooming or scrolling sideways?

  4. Question 4 of 5

    Is every attorney listed still at the firm, and is every practice area you take on today there?

  5. Question 5 of 5

    Could a stranger tell, in under a minute, what you do, where you are and how to reach you? Bonus if they can tell what a first consultation costs.

Any "no"? Get a free written review of your site.

A "no" on questions 1 to 3 puts you among the 830. A "no" on 4 or 5 means the site works but is quietly costing you calls. Either way, most of these are an afternoon's fix.

Where we come in

I co-founded SettledSites with Mark Jarvis, who has been building websites at his own design studio for years. We only work with Illinois solo attorneys and small law firms. We write, build and maintain the site, and after launch we keep it current: email us a new fee, attorney or office hours, and it's changed, usually within one business day. You own your domain and your files, and you approve every page.

You don't need us to run the test above. But if your site failed it and you'd rather not be the one keeping it alive, that's the part we take off your plate.

Get a free written review of your firm's site

Questions lawyers ask about this

How many Illinois law firm websites have problems?

In my October 2026 check, 830 of 5,241 (16%) had at least one: the site didn't load, wasn't secure, or didn't display properly on a phone.

Does an "http" website hurt a law firm?

Browsers mark it "Not secure" next to your name, and many visitors leave on that alone. In my data, 7% of Illinois firm sites that loaded still use http.

How many law firms publish their fees online?

In Illinois, about 2%: 104 of 5,182 firm websites showed a clearly labeled fee.

Is my firm named in this study?

No. I'm only publishing statewide totals, not a list of firms.

How I counted: in October 2026 I fetched the homepage of every Illinois law firm website in the LawyerPricing directory (5,241 sites) and checked whether it loaded, whether it used HTTPS, whether it had a mobile viewport tag and how many pages the site had. HTTPS and mobile figures use the 4,799 sites that loaded. The fee figure comes from a separate October 2026 review of 5,182 firm websites. LawyerPricing is SettledSites' sister site; both are run by the same founder. We're web designers, not a law firm, and nothing here is legal advice.

Keep reading