Short answer: Your website did its job the moment someone filled out the form or hit call. Everything after that is on you. Studies keep finding the same thing: the faster you respond, the better your odds, and most law firms are slow. When Clio's secret shoppers called 500 firms, almost half never picked up or called back. Call back in minutes, not days.
We spend most of our time talking about how to get the phone to ring. This post is about what happens when it does. Because a great website that hands leads to a slow front desk is a very expensive way to help the firm down the street.
67%of law firms never answered a potential client's emailClio, 2024
48%of law firms couldn't be reached by phone, even after callbacksClio, 2024
80%+of people looking for a lawyer will contact another one if they don't hear back within 48 hoursMartindale-Avvo, 2023
Why does response time matter so much?
Because people looking for a lawyer usually aren't looking for just one. In Martindale-Avvo's 2023 survey, about 8 in 10 people who hired a lawyer had contacted more than one first, and 46% named being slow to respond as a reason not to hire someone.
A study by MIT and InsideSales.com of more than 15,000 leads found that the odds of qualifying a lead dropped 21 times when the call came at 30 minutes instead of 5. And the odds of even reaching the person dropped more than 10 times in the first hour.
That study wasn't about law firms. (And it's from 2007.) But think about who calls a lawyer. Someone just got served, arrested, injured or left. They're not browsing. They want someone to tell them what happens next, today.
How slow are law firms?
Slower than you'd hope. Clio runs secret shopper tests where people pose as potential clients and contact real firms. In 2024 they contacted 500 firms by email and phone. 67% never answered the email, and 48% didn't answer the phone or call back.
Both numbers were worse than when Clio ran the same test in 2019. And here's the kicker: in Clio's 2019 report, 89% of legal professionals said they respond to calls and emails within 24 hours.
In the lawyer forums we read, a law office staffer put it better than any study: "people don't hire the best lawyers. They hire the lawyers who pick up the phone."
How fast should a law firm call back a new lead?
Within minutes if you can. Within the hour at the latest. Same business day, every time, no exceptions.
I know that sounds like a lot when you're in court half the day. That's why the answer isn't "try harder." The answer is setting things up so the lead can't sit there.
What should happen the moment a lead comes in?
Here's a simple setup that works for a solo or a small firm:
- You get a text, not just an email. Emails get buried. A text alert with the person's name, number and what they need gets read in the hallway between hearings.
- They get an instant reply. An automatic email or text that says you got their message, when you'll call, and your number. Keep it human: "Thanks, I'm in court until 2, I'll call you by 3."
- Missed calls get a text back. If nobody can pick up, the caller gets a text right away so they don't move on to the next name.
- Someone owns the callback. You, a paralegal or an answering service. One name, not "whoever sees it."
- Every lead gets written down. Name, date, how they found you, and whether you called back. After a month you'll know exactly where your leads come from and how many you're letting slip.
When we build a site, we check your contact page and auto-replies against your state's advertising rules before anything goes live, because an auto-reply is still a communication from your firm.
How do I know if my firm is losing leads after the website?
Test yourself. It takes ten minutes and it's humbling.
- Fill out your own contact form from your phone, on a weeknight, and time how long it takes for anyone to respond.
- Ask a friend to call your office at lunch and again at 5:30 pm. (Not from your own phone: if you're the one who answers, you'll just get a busy signal.) Did a human pick up? Could they even leave a message, or was the voicemail full? Did the voicemail say when you'd call back? Did anyone actually call them back?
- Check that your form actually sends somewhere someone reads. Forms break quietly, and old email addresses stay hooked up for years.
- Look at the last ten leads. How many got a callback the same day?
If you don't like the answers, fix that before you spend another dollar on marketing. More leads into a leaky bucket just means more leaks.
Where our job ends and yours starts. Your website's job is to make the phone ring and the form fill up. Our job is to make sure that happens, and that the lead lands in front of you fast. Your job is the part no website can do: pick up, listen, and make that person feel like they called the right lawyer. Now you do you, and wow that client.
If your site isn't sending many leads in the first place, start with why a law firm website doesn't get calls.
Want to know how many leads your site is sending, and where they're getting stuck? Free review, in writing.
Questions lawyers ask about lead response time
How quickly should a lawyer respond to a new client inquiry?
Same business day at the latest. In the same Martindale-Avvo survey, 40% said they'd contact another attorney if they didn't hear back within 24 hours, and over 80% within 48 hours. More in how fast to call back.
Should I use an answering service for my law firm?
If you can't reliably answer or return calls within an hour, yes. A good legal answering service takes the caller's details, reassures them, and gets the message to you right away. Make sure they follow a short script you approve, and that they never give legal advice.
Is an automatic reply to a website inquiry okay for a law firm?
Yes, as long as it's accurate and doesn't promise results. See the simple setup for what to say.
What should I say when I call a new lead back?
Use their name, show you read what they wrote, and tell them what happens next: a consultation, what to bring, and what it costs. People remember the lawyer who listened. You can talk about fees and strategy once you know whether you can help.
How do I track where my leads come from?
Ask every new caller how they found you and write it down in one place. Add tracking to your website form and use separate phone numbers for listings and ads if you can. After a few months you'll see which sources bring real clients, not just calls.
Sources
- Clio, Client intake and the Legal Trends Report (2024 secret shopper study)
- Above the Law, on the Clio 2019 Legal Trends Report
- Martindale-Avvo, Understanding the Legal Consumer 2023
- MIT and InsideSales.com, Lead Response Management Study (2007)
- Above the Law, on the Clio 2024 Legal Trends Report secret shopper study
- 2Civility, Clio 2024 Legal Trends Report summary
- Law office staff comment in r/LawFirm, July 2025
Written by Gaston Sitbon and Mark Jarvis, co-founders of SettledSites. Facts checked November 5, 2026.
Keep reading
See your own firm's new homepage before you pay anything.


